Why do dormers leak so often?
A dormer adds two side walls that rise out of the sloped roof, a front wall, and its own small roof. Everywhere the main roof meets those walls, water has to be turned away by metal flashing. On a Cape with a long shed dormer, that can mean dozens of feet of joints, each one a potential leak.
Many dormers in Hicksville were added decades after the house was built, and the roof has been replaced since. If the flashing was reused, face-nailed or done as one long piece instead of individual steps, it eventually lets water in. Sections like Hillside Terrace, full of early-1950s Capes, see this pattern often.
How is dormer flashing supposed to work?
- Step flashing: one L-shaped piece per shingle course along each side wall, each overlapping the one below.
- Counterflashing or siding: the wall cladding laps over the step flashing so water can't run behind it.
- Apron flashing: a continuous piece along the bottom of the dormer's front wall.
- Clearance: siding should stop slightly above the shingles so debris and water don't get trapped.
When any of those layers is missing or installed in the wrong order, water finds its way behind the siding and into the wall or the space behind the knee wall.
What are the signs of failed dormer flashing?
- Stains on the ceiling or wall below a dormer.
- Water marks in the low attic spaces behind knee walls.
- Peeling paint or soft trim at the bottom of dormer walls.
- Rusty or lifted metal where the dormer meets the roof.
- Heavy caulk along the joint, a sign of past patching.
- Leaks that appear only in wind-driven rain.
Those small doors in a Cape's upstairs rooms lead to the low attic spaces where dormer leaks show up first. Check them with a flashlight after heavy rain.
Why do so many Hicksville homes have dormers?
Many of the houses built in Hicksville during the post-war boom were Cape Cods with an unfinished or partly finished upper half-story. As families grew, owners added shed and gable dormers to turn that space into full bedrooms and bathrooms. Over the years, that became one of the most common ways to expand a Cape on Long Island.
Each of those additions was built by a different contractor at a different time, and many have since been re-roofed one or more times. That's why dormer flashing quality varies so much from house to house, and why two neighbors with similar homes can have very different leak histories. If you're buying or own a dormered Cape, it's worth having the dormer joints checked whenever the roof is inspected.
How do roofers fix dormer flashing?
The lasting repair is to open the joint: remove the shingles along the wall and the bottom course of siding, install new step flashing piece by piece over a strip of ice and water membrane, add apron flashing where needed, and reinstall the siding with proper clearance. We photograph the new flashing before covering it.
Our guide to roof flashing repair explains the process in detail, and roof flashing repair in Field Estates covers the older homes in one of Hicksville's historic sections. To get a dormer checked, visit our Hicksville roof leak help page.
Smearing caulk along a leaking dormer joint hides the problem and can trap water. Replacing the flashing is the real repair.
Frequently asked questions
Does the siding have to come off to fix dormer flashing?
Usually the bottom course or two, so new step flashing can tuck behind it. Vinyl siding comes off and goes back easily.
Why is the leak on a lower floor if the dormer is upstairs?
Water can run down inside the wall or behind the knee wall before it shows up on a ceiling below.
Should dormer flashing be replaced when I re-roof?
Yes. Reusing old flashing under new shingles is one of the most common causes of dormer leaks.
Can I check dormer flashing myself?
From the ground with binoculars and from the knee-wall spaces inside, yes. Leave roof work to a pro.